Some events trigger intense divisions within a community. Examples include controversies involving police practices, school shootings, immigration policies, political speakers at a university campus, or situations unmasked by the #MeToo movement. There is a resurgent interest in using “third-party interveners” such as mediators and facilitators to help community leaders and citizens address such matters. If a person were to mediate such a situation, what does – or would – a “successful mediation intervention” look like?